What do you get when you pillarbox a letterbox?
November 3rd, 2008Okay, as many know, I recently splashed out a large sum for a widescreen panel in my lounge. It’s great having a widescreen picture with a 40″ diagonal. So, do you want to know what really s**ts me about it? There appears to be an entire countrry (*cough* North America *cough*) who are yet to acknowledge the exisstence of a 16:9 aspect ratio on broadcast television.
The problem? They somehow think that everyone with a 4:3 TV wants to watch things in widescreen. The end result is a letterbox.
So this:
Becomes this:
Well, that’s all well and good, if you still happen to be running a 4:3 television, AND you’d rather see the (often irrrelevant) picture to the sides rather than use your whole screen. At this point, a 4:3 screen is utilising exactly three quarters of its available area to display a picture.
…but what if I own a widescreen TV? How do you put a 4:3 letterbox on it? That’s right - you pillar-box it!:
At this point, only nine sixteenths of the screen is actually being utilised. That’s 44% of the panel unnecessarily displaying black. My 40″ screen is now 30″. That’s just freakin’ great!
Oh, and I’m not done yet. I happen to know some people with a 4:3 TV, and they hook up a Set Top Box and set it to letterbox. What you end up with is a picture that is letter-boxed, pillar-boxed and then letter-boxed again. Can anyone say “postage stamp”?:
At this point, the image is only taking up 27/64 (42%) of the screen. It’s at this point that I just get up and change whatever ill-conceived settings happen to be applied to the set top box. It’s just painful when someone decides to use this technique to convert their 51cm CRT to a 29cm screen. Hell, I’ve got a laptop with a bigger screen than that!
TV has been broadcast in widescreen since January 2000. Why the hell haven’t broadcasters adapted to it? And why the hell do people think they’re being trendy by letter-boxing? Get over it. You’ve got a 4:3 screen, deal with the 4:3 picture!
It eludes me that stations still broadcast images which have been both letter-boxed and pillar-boxed.





